Over the past decade, live-action movies have grown in popularity, retelling the tales of beloved animated films. Disney, in particular, has been making many live-action films, totaling over twenty films. Live-action movies are met with a range of opinions. Some people love the new takes on films, while others do not.
“I don’t have a set opinion on the genre as a whole, I try to take each one on a case-by-case basis. That being said, many live-action movies fail to capture the spark that made the originals such standouts,” said Mercury Hasty (12).
Live-action films offer a range of opportunities for the movie. Some closely follow the original’s plot, and other adaptations add new aspects to the storyline. With these latest additions comes controversy. Some audiences think live-action films should replicate the exact style of their animated film. Sometimes, this expectation is unattainable, especially considering the nature of the animation. On the same note, some argue that if the live-action is going to be the same, then there is no purpose in recreating the film.
Live-action movies are a way to bring people’s favorite movies, characters, and worlds to life.
“One of my personal favorite remakes is The Jungle Book (2016). It felt fresh and unique but familiar and comforting at the same time,” Hasty said.
There is also controversy regarding the looks of certain characters in movie remakes. In May 2023, Disney released their live-action remake of The Little Mermaid. Halle Bailey portrayed Ariel. When this casting decision was announced, many people on social media were angry. There were negative reactions as people argued that Ariel was supposed to be white with red hair.
Sadly, this is a normal reaction when actors take the role of a previously white character. When Rick Riordan’s Percy Jackson was announced as a TV show and the cast was revealed, people were angry that Leah Jeffries, a fifteen-year-old actress, was cast as Annabeth Chase. They argued that she was white and blonde in the books, so she should be portrayed the same way in the TV show. Racist fans were outraged, even though Riordan himself picked the cast for the show.
The most recent casting in a live-action movie that upset fans was in the upcoming live-action reiteration of How to Train Your Dragon, which will be released in June 2025. Nico Parker, a nineteen-year-old actress, was cast as Astrid Haddock. When her role was announced, people were yet again mad that she didn’t fit the blonde hair and blue eye stereotype.
As always, several people have several opinions about live-action remakes. Some think live-action movies must be identical to the original characters. Others believe the role should go to whomever the best actress is for the role, regardless of their physical appearance.
The only people who seem to have a problem with the casting decisions of these movies are adults. Many young children enjoy seeing these movies, regardless of an actor’s race. They are simply there for the story. Additionally, children worldwide enjoy having representation on the big screen, whether it be from the original character or their live-action rendition, like with Halle Bailey playing Ariel.
“Personally, I enjoy watching the new live-action movies. I think if people are going to complain, they just shouldn’t watch them. The original movie still exists and no one is forcing them to watch the new one,” said Emily Brooks (12).
Due to their success and popularity in the media, it is clear to see that live-action movies will continue to be released. Good or bad, producers will make these films and society will watch them time and time again to form their own opinions and ideas regarding the plot and characters.
